Menu About Why Us Contact (845) 342-4814
Middletown's Favorite Sub Shop

Every Sub Built the Way You Order It — Fresh, Fast, and Actually Satisfying

No shortcuts. No stale bread. Just quality ingredients stacked high on fresh-baked rolls, made to order right in front of you.

View Our Menu Get Directions
125 W Main St, Middletown
Open Today
Made-to-Order Every Time
Interior of Amber's Sub Shop
Making a fresh sub sandwich
About Us

A Local Spot That Puts the Work In

Amber's Sub Shop has been a fixture on West Main Street for years — not because we chase trends, but because we do one thing and do it well. Every sandwich is assembled from scratch, every ingredient chosen for quality, and every order treated like it matters.

We're not a chain. We're not trying to be. We're the place Middletown comes to when they want a real sandwich — the kind with fresh bread, generous toppings, and none of the rush. Walk in, order your way, and eat like you're supposed to.

Locally Owned

Part of this community, for this community.

Fresh Daily

Bread and ingredients arrive fresh every morning.

Right Here

125 W Main St — easy to find, easy to stop by.

Why Amber's

The Difference Is in the Details

Anyone can stack meat on bread. We make sure every layer earns its place.

Made to Order

Nothing comes pre-made. Your sub is built from start to finish after you order — that's how fresh it should be.

Quality Ingredients

We source the meats, cheeses, and produce we're proud to put in front of you. No cut corners, no filler.

Fast & Friendly

You won't wait long, and you'll leave feeling like you matter. Good food moves quicker when it's made right.

Catering Available

Office lunch? Family gathering? We'll build a spread that works for your group and shows up on time.

Walk Ins Welcome

No reservation needed. Just walk in on West Main Street and we'll get you taken care of.

Community First

We know our regulars by name. This isn't just a business — it's part of Middletown's daily rhythm.

Hungry? Come See What Fresh Tastes Like.

Stop by on West Main Street or give us a call. We'll have your sub ready before you know it.

Find Us Call (845) 342-4814
Contact

Visit Us on Main Street

We're right in the heart of Middletown. Pull up, walk in, or give us a ring — we're always happy to help.

Address

125 W Main St
Middletown, NY 10940-4935

Hours

Mon – Fri: 10:00 AM – 8:00 PM
Saturday: 11:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Sunday: Closed

Send Us a Message

Have a question about catering, large orders, or anything else? Drop us a line and we'll get back to you.

Amber's Sub Shop

125 W Main St, Middletown, NY 10940-4935

Open in Google Maps
Is this your business?This is my business